Skip to Content

How to Make Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Better?

If you want your canned cherry pie filling to have a nicer taste, try adding some fruit to it. To give it a unique flavor, try switching things up by including a can of fruit that has been sliced or diced in the recipe. The canned cherry pie filling will acquire a sour taste due to the addition of the fruit, resulting in a distinct flavor from that of a canned cherry pie filling that is bland. Even though this approach does not always work, it is still worthwhile to test it.

Many different recipes are available, and many call for canned cherry pie filling. These mouthwatering sweets are great for both the summer and the winter. There is a sweet cherry variety and a sour cherry variety, and Rainier and Bing are two examples of the sweet variety. The filling for tart cherry pies is almost always made with the tart variety. In the following paragraphs, you will find some suggestions for improving the flavor of canned cherry pie. Continue reading to learn how to improve the flavor of canned apricot jam or raspberry pie sauce by using the can.

What does Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Like?

The majority of ready-made pie fillings have a tendency to be quite sweet, but cherry pie filling is not like the others. Because cherries have a naturally sour flavor, the filling for a cherry pie may not have as sweet of a taste as you would want. Choose a cherry jelly or jam for a flavor that is just a little bit sweeter.

Even though there is no substitute for a handcrafted cherry pie, there is no shame in using a canned filling, even if this significantly reduces the room for mistakes. In addition, some store-bought pie filling may be rather delectable. As a result, we did what we always do: purchase every brand of cherry pie filling that we could locate and bake pies while using the same dough for each one.

How to Make Canned Cherry Pie Filling Taste Better?

The good news is that grocery stores, convenience stores, and other retail establishments stock a wide selection of cherry pie fillings and a variety of fruit pie crusts in various sizes, thicknesses, flavors, and types of pie dough. The jars that they frequently come packaged in are full of sugary syrup and pitted cherries prepared in various ways. For example, the cherries may be drenched in the syrup as soon as they are picked, or the cherries may be partially dried out before being drenched in the syrup. Unfortunately, even when using the cherry pie filling of your choice, you might discover that a little something is missing, whether in terms of flavor or texture. Do not give up on enjoying this delectable dessert; rather, give some of these suggestions a shot to perk up your cherry pie. Continue reading if you want to learn how to improve the flavor of canned cherry pie filling.

  • The aroma of a freshly baked pie fills our homes with joy, and we all share that sentiment. When you use canned filling options in addition, making pies can be a straightforward process.
  • The only thing left to do is add the crust, and if you want the absolute simplest solution possible, there are even options for crusts that have already been remade. The issue is that those canned fillings do not always have an amazing flavor when consumed directly from the can.
  • When it comes to cherry pie filling, this is possibly one of the most noticeable pie fillings that require just a little bit of extra care and attention to achieve the ideal flavor.
  • You may have noticed that when cherry pie filling is first removed from the can, it doesn’t have as much sweetness as it does later on, and it can also be a little bit sour.
  • How can you improve the flavor of cherry pie filling that has been canned? Adding white sugar, typically at a rate of one tablespoon at a time, is an easy way to improve the flavor and sweetness of canned cherry pie filling. The result is typically a more flavorful pie and satisfying to eat. Instead, you could also use pineapple juice or sweet syrup, such as agave or honey.

What is the Purpose of Canned Cherry Pie Filling?

Most canned cherry pie filling comes from cherries that aren’t fully ripe. They may be tart even when they’re at their best. The flavor may be influenced by the filling procedure used by some brands.

Canned cherry pie filling comes in various sizes and flavors and different levels of tartness. You might come across a brand with the technique down that always produces deliciously sweet cherries. When it comes to canned products, though, it’s safe to say that you won’t always receive perfectly ripe cherries, which is why most canned cherry pie fillings are a little tart.

There are a few options for preserving your cherry pie filling. Some of these can be used together, while others can be used alone, and any technique will be successful.


You can sweeten your cherry pie filling with a simple addition of any white sugar, and this is arguably the most common and straightforward method of sweetening cherry pie filling.

There are a few different approaches you can take here. Some individuals recommend combining the sugar with a small amount of water and simmering it to get a syrupy liquid. Because most pie fillings already contain that syrupy combination, you may add the sugar to the premade pie filling.

If your cherry pie filling lacks the syrupy combination, you can make it with syrup and water and then combine it with your cherry pie filling.

  • We will presume that your cherry pie filling contains a syrupy mixture for this article.
  • Here’s how to use sugar to sweeten your canned cherry pie filling.
  • Pour the cherry pie filling from the can into a mixing bowl.
  • One tablespoon sugar, well mixed into the cherry pie filling.
  • To test if the filling is sweet enough, take a small dab and taste it.
  • Continue to add sugar in 1 teaspoon increments if the filling is still too tart.
  • Before adding extra sugar, stir it thoroughly each time and test it.
  • As you can see, this is a simple method that will have your cherry pie filling tasting fantastic in no time!
  • Let’s have a look at some other possibilities now.


This could be an excellent solution for sweetening up your cherry pie filling if you have a jam or jelly that you think will go well with cherry pie filling (ideally cherry). Because jam and jelly are naturally sweetened and have a texture that will combine well with pie filling, you should have no problems.

This is a straightforward procedure, but if your jam or jelly is too thick, you may need to add a little fruit juice to thin it down. Check out these instructions for using jam or jelly to sweeten canned cherry pie filling.

  • Fill a mixing bowl halfway with canned cherry pie filling.
  • Toss in 4 tablespoons of jam or jelly into the batter.
  • This should be thoroughly mixed in.
  • Add a little amount of complimentary fruit juice if the mixture seems too thick after adding the jam or jelly.
  • Stir well once more. Test the flavor to make sure it’s sweetened and tastes good.
  • If you have other ingredients on hand, don’t go out and buy jam or jelly. This choice will affect the overall texture of your mixture in some way.
  • If you have jam or jelly on hand, though, and this is what you prefer, it’s a terrific choice!


The good thing is that the flavors of cherry and pineapple are compatible, so they complement each other wonderfully to make it sweet. Unless you overdo it, your cherry pie will not taste like pineapple.

If canned peaches, cooked apples, or even simply some mixed berries sound better to you, some people advocate trying these.

  • Here’s how to use pineapple or another sweet fruit to sweeten canned pie filling.
  • Fill a mixing bowl halfway with canned cherry pie filling.
  • To make the cherry pie filling, add a small amount of pineapple juice, pineapple pieces, or even pureed pineapple. We recommend adding roughly four tablespoons for each can of cherry pie filling.
  • Mix everything up thoroughly.
  • This is yet another straightforward procedure. For the process, you can use pineapple juice, fresh pineapple, or canned pineapple, and all of them will work great.
  • If you’re going to use pineapple juice instead of tidbits or chunks, start with around two teaspoons instead of 4, and modify from there if necessary.


In most situations, canned cherry pie filling is meant to be syrupy, so adding a syrupy component when you need to sweeten it up just a tiny more makes sense. You have various options to pick from in this scenario. You may create this with any thick, syrupy sweetener.

Corn syrup, maple syrup, agave nectar, or honey are good options. All of these are thick and syrupy in texture, and extremely sweet.

Follow the steps below.

  • Pour the cherry pie filling into a mixing bowl once opened.
  • One spoonful at a time, drizzle your preferred syrupy sweetness into the pie filling.
  • Mix it in thoroughly.
  • Carry out a taste test. You can add an extra spoonful of your additive if you need more sweetness. Will add 1-3 tablespoons of syrup to every 12 ounces of canned cherry pie filling in most circumstances.
  • Most of us have one or more of these ingredients in our cupboard, and they go wonderfully with cherry pie filling.
  • The sweetness and syrupy texture produce the required outcomes while not altering your cherry pie filling significantly.

Additional Alternatives

Whether you’re still seeking an alternative and aren’t sure if any of the above solutions are right for you, here are a few more options to consider!

  • 14 cup cherry glaze per 12 ounces pie filling
  • 1-2 cups whipped topping per can of pie filling
  • One small can of sweetened condensed milk, heat on low with the cherry pie filling to achieve the desired thickness.
  • In this tutorial, we will demonstrate how you can improve the flavor of your canned cherry pie filling using various techniques.

These options are very straightforward, and it’s highly likely that you already have all of the necessary ingredients stocked in your pantry. There are times when just a little bit of sugar can go a very long way.

How can I Make the Cherry Flavor more Prominent?

If the cherries you use are very sour, you may want to consider adding two tablespoons of sugar to the filling. On the other hand, if the cherries you use are sweet and juicy, you may want to consider adding a teaspoon of lemon juice and a little bit of lemon zest to give the filling some acidity to balance out the sweetness.

Do You have Any Experience Baking Cherry Pie Filling?

Prepare the oven per the instructions. To make a Two-Crust Filled Pie, prepare the filling and follow the directions on the package. If you want the cherry filling to have a more robust flavor, consider adding one teaspoon of almond extract and stirring it in. Put a large sheet of heavy-duty aluminum foil on the lowest oven rack to collect any juices that might spill out the pan.

Should the Filling for the Pie be Cold or Hot?

Before adding any fillings to the pastry case, you should wait for them to cool thoroughly. Preheating a baking dish and then cooking the pie on it may prevent a moist filling from turning the pastry foundation into a soggy mess. The additional heat will help the dough firm more quickly.

Which Cheese is Most Complimentary to Cherries?

The following silky cheeses, Camembert, brie, cream cheese, and ricotta, benefit from the brightening effect that cherries have on them: buffalo mozzarella. Blue cheeses: Cherries, which are so adaptable, can even be paired with blue cheese, which has a sharp flavor. Match them with a blue cheese such as Gorgonzola, Roquefort, stilt on, or Maytag Blue.


It will be tastier if you add sugar to canned cherry pie filling. You can also top your pie with more fruit. Adding more fruit to the mix will help keep the gel in place. You’ll have a rich and wonderful dessert once you’ve added the fruits. If you have a sweet tooth, you can add an extra tablespoon of sugar to the recipe. This will improve the flavor of the canned cherry pie filling. Add additional sugar to canned cherry pie filling to improve the flavor. The canned cherries should have a syrupy consistency. 

Can add different fruits to the filling to make it sweeter. You can serve the pie without worrying about how it will taste once you’ve added enough sugar. You may also try enhancing the flavor of the canned cherry pie by adding some additional fruit. You may also add pineapple juice to the mix to amp up the flavor.

Subscribe to Blog Chef for the easiest recipes and cooking tips, straight to your inbox. Signing up gives your consent to emails and personalized ads.