Home » Cooking Tips » Can I Substitute Butter for Oil in Brownies?

Can I Substitute Butter for Oil in Brownies?

One of the most enjoyable kitchen activities is making brownies. It produces not only delectable, addictive, and moreish snacks, but it is also extremely rewarding and enjoyable in and of itself. It’s a great way to get the kids involved in the kitchen while teaching them important decision-making skills. There are many cool and exciting recipes out there that use various ingredients and inspirations.

However, with so much room for flavor and ingredient variation, it begs whether We can replace essential ingredients like eggs with other ingredients.

Many of us have set out to make brownies only to discover that we’re missing key ingredients! Oil is the most frequently overlooked ingredient.

You’re probably reading this because you want to know if any products can replace oil so that you can keep making your dream brownies.

Is it possible to use butter instead of oil? Let’s find out so you can go to chocolate heaven and eat all those delicious brownies you’ve been craving.

Can I Substitute Butter for Oil in Brownies?

When making brownies, you can use butter instead of oil, and butter has a high oil content naturally, making it an excellent substitute. To keep the flavor of the brownies as consistent as possible, use unflavored, unsalted butter in place of the oil.
However, if you want your brownies to have a slightly saltier flavor, you can use salted butter.

How do you Make Brownies with Butter Instead of Oil?

If you make brownies with butter instead of oil, use the same amount of butter as you would with oil.
After that, melt the butter until it becomes liquid. After that, you can use it however you want after it has cooled slightly.

Butter is a great alternative to oil because it allows your brownies to melt on your tongue, making them more moist and enjoyable to eat. This makes each bite even better than the last!

What can you Use Instead of Oil in Brownies?

Margarine

Amazon.com: Best Foods Margarine 150g. Made in Thailand : Everything Else

What is a better substitute for vegetable oil than margarine, which is a by-product of it? It’s the best spread on bread or sprinkled on crackers, and it’s frequently used in place of butter, which is also a vegetable oil substitute.
When most people need a substitute for shortenings, they usually go for margarine. So, if you’re unsure if your Crisco will go rancid and don’t want to take the risk, go with margarine next time. You’re unlikely to notice the difference because it’s so minor.
Margarine has a buttery flavor that is mildly pleasant. As a result, you can rest assured that brownies’ naturally sweet and rich chocolate flavor is unaffected. It also gives brownies a smooth exterior that tempts people to bite into them.
Replace one serving of vegetable oil with the same amount of margarine.

Olive Oil

Disano Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 1L : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Olive oil is another option to consider when you don’t have vegetable oil on hand. Some people prefer to use it as a dressing, while others prefer to drizzle it over pasta, and still, others think it’s best in brownies.
Olive oil is distinguished from other types by its distinct aroma and flavor, which varies depending on quality, age, and other factors. Top-quality bottles, for example, have a pleasant grassy flavor, whereas those at the lower end of the price spectrum taste like oil.

Because healthy olive oils can be overpowering, opt for light or extra light varieties instead. When you add it to the brownie batter, you’ll notice a big difference in flavor: fruity undertones with a smidgeon of bitterness.
Olive oil is unique in that We can substitute it for various other oils, and olive oil is one of the most widely available alternatives to peanut oil. When it comes to the best sesame oil substitutes, olive oil is the clear winner. Follow the 1:1 ratio when substituting olive oil for vegetable oil.

Butter

Amazon.com: AMUL Butter 200 GM (Pack of 4) : Grocery & Gourmet Food

There are two types of people in this world: those who use vegetable oil in their desserts and those who use butter or margarine. Here’s the lowdown on each ingredient’s benefits and drawbacks.

Butter is primarily composed of fat (80%), milk solids (5%), and water (15 percent ). Although insignificant, the amount of water in your brownies impacts and thickens the flour, making it less airy and tender in texture. Because vegetable oil is only fat, this does not happen.

When it comes to taste, however, butter is unquestionably superior. It gives your chocolatey treats a deep richness, making them more indulgent. As a result, butter doesn’t seem like a bad idea when you’re out of options.

You can also trust butter not to affect the average length brownies stay fresh because butter lasts a long time, which is why butter is still one of the most popular vegetable oil substitutes in brownies.
Substitute one tablespoon of butter for one tablespoon of vegetable oil.

Canola Oil

DiSano Canola Oil, For all Cooking needs, Lowest in Saturated Fat, 5L : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Many people dislike canola oil because it is often thought to harm people’s health. They are not incorrect, however, because it is derived from rapeseed. Canola oil, on the other hand, is perfectly safe to consume once refined and processed.

Studies have shown that canola oil is low in saturated fat and high in essential vitamins. It has a neutral flavor, so it’s a great substitute for vegetable oil in brownie recipes when vegetable oil isn’t available.

Because of its high smoking point, canola oil is also one of the best oils for making popcorn. Canola oil is great when you want the added seasonings and flavors to shine, but it’s not as rich or buttery as coconut oil, a classic combination for popcorn.

If the recipe calls for a cup of vegetable oil, use the same amount of canola oil instead.

Avocado Oil

Olivado Extra Virgin Avocado Oil, 500ml : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

We can use avocado oil in various ways, including pan-fried dishes, barbecues, and baked goods. It has many health benefits, including lowering cholesterol, improving eye health, and speeding up wound healing.
Avocado oil has a delicate flavor that won’t overpower your brownies. Instead, it adds a buttery richness to the sweet, earthy flavor. Avocado oil, like vegetable oil, does a fantastic job of keeping the center moist and tender.
The ratio of substitutes would also be 1:1.

Sunflower Oil

Fortune Sunlite Refined Sunflower Oil, 5L Can : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Sunflower oil has a long history in medicine. It’s long been linked to good skin, hair, and heart health (2), but it’s also a kitchen staple. It’s commonly used as a frying oil or to make creamy mayonnaise because of its high smoking point and nutty flavor.

When used in brownies, sunflower oil works in the same way as vegetable oil. It transforms the interior, making it extra squishy. If you’re one of those supertasters, you’ll detect nutty undertones in brownies made with sunflower oil.
We can use sunflower oil instead of olive oil in a 1:1 ratio.

Coconut Oil

Amazon.com: Organic Coconut Oil, Cold-Pressed - Natural Hair Oil, Skin Oil and Cooking Oil with Fresh Flavor, Non-GMO Unrefined Extra Virgin Coconut Oil (Aceite de Coco), USDA Organic, 16 oz

Coconut oil, one of my favorites on the list, is well worth the hype. It’s a multipurpose beauty product, a health booster, and a key ingredient that instantly transforms your dessert into a crowd-pleaser.
Coconut oil is extremely popular due to its sweet, nutty aroma. Unfortunately, when baked, this characteristic is lost. Coconut oil, like other alternatives, will give brownies a wonderful texture, and you can be sure you won’t be able to stop at just one.
Coconut oil that has been refined is the best option, and the substitute ratio is also one to one.

Shortening

CCDS Bakers Shortening, 900 Grams Cooking Food Baking : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Since the 18th century, people have been shortening their sentences. We made traditional versions of the product with vegetable oil or animal fat, but modern versions are mostly associated with the first option. It’s usually used to make baked goods have a better texture.

That isn’t to say that shortening is a perfect substitute for vegetable oil. Because it’s a solid fat, when beaten, it allows air to enter the batter, resulting in a cakey texture. This should be your last resort if you can’t find any of the oil mentioned above substitutes.

Melt an equal amount of shortening to replace one tablespoon of vegetable oil.

Other Useful Vegetable Oil Substitutes that you can Use

Applesauce

Simple Truth Organic Unswettened Applesauce -23 Oz : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Applesauce is delicious and can also be used as a vegetable oil in brownies. Yes, that is correct. The best part is that you can easily make applesauce at home or purchase a jar at any local grocery store or supermarket.

Most people are wary of this substitution because applesauce has a distinct fruity flavor that may clash with the chocolatey flavor of brownies. However, you’ll be relieved to learn that only the consistency is affected – in a good way.

When it comes to figuring out how to make cakes from a brownie mix, applesauce does a fantastic job of keeping brownies moist and fudgy. Furthermore, the sauce is a great weight-loss option because it is low in calories. These two are a made-in-heaven couple.

The ratio of substitutes is 1:1. Reduce the amount of sauce by 14 cups if the flavor is too strong. Also, use a smaller amount of sugar than the recipe calls for.

Pureed fruit

Ormeal 100% Organic Baby Food Puree Fruit for 6 Months + Baby, EU Certified, Only Apple + Strawberry + Banana Mix Fruit (Pack of 1) : Amazon.in: Clothing & Accessories

If you can replace vegetable oil with applesauce (apple puree), you should be able to do so with other fruits. Mild flavors, such as avocado or banana, are recommended, but feel free to use whatever you have on hand.
It’s a thing when you combine fruit puree and brownies, and they will puff up and become more cake-like when baked in the oven, rather than being flat. You’ll also have to be cautious with liquid content; if you don’t, you’ll end up with a batch of soggy chocolate cubes.
Reduce the liquid ingredients by half and replace one tablespoon of vegetable oil with one tablespoon of fruit puree.

Vanilla Extract

Farmown Pure Indian Vanilla Extract 100ml : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Many desserts lose their allure without vanilla extract, and it has a lovely scent that will lift your spirits from the first whiff. Vanilla is the star of many hot beverages, savory meals, cakes, and pastries.
And, yes, vanilla extract can be used in place of vegetable oil as long as the amount of sugar used is reduced; otherwise, your brownies will be far too sweet. Vanilla does not improve the texture much, but it does make your treats taste a million times better.

Because there is no exact ratio for this option, start with a small amount. Otherwise, the intense sweetness will overpower the brownies’ chocolate flavor.

Greek Yogurt

Epigamia Natural Greek Yogurt, 400g : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Yogurt is delicious, but did you know that We can add a dollop to brownie batter? If you didn’t, it’s not too late to give this bold move a shot, especially if you’re out of vegetable oil and need a replacement.
Yogurt’s characteristic tartness is initially thought to clash with brownies’ chocolate flavor. The outcome, on the other hand, is completely unexpected. The flavor is unmatched, and you’ll be surprised at how moist and tender it is on the tongue.

We can use vegetable oil in place of yogurt in a 1:1 ratio. We can substitute twelve cups of yogurt and two eggs for 12 cups of vegetable oil in a box recipe.

Buttermilk

Amul Butter Milk - Spiced, 1L Tetra Pack : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Buttermilk is another daily product that We can substitute for yogurt, and it’s made with butter, milk, and a choice of acid, as the name implies. It’s tangy, but not so much that it overpowers the chocolate flavor of the brownies.

Buttermilk is prized for its ability to make baked goods rise, but that doesn’t mean it will last long. We can keep it in the fridge for about two weeks, but it should be discarded once a strange odor or mold appears.
A half-cup of buttermilk equals one tablespoon of vegetable oil. Reduce the baking time by about 10 minutes or add a little water to prevent the finished products from drying.

Cornstarch

Desire Baker's Corn Starch 200 Gram : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Surprisingly, cornstarch is an excellent substitute for vegetable oil. It’s been added to brownie batter for a long time, resulting in a delicious batch of brownies with crispy edges and a super-moist center.
Combine cornstarch and water, then heat the mixture until it reaches the desired consistency. Combine the ingredients in a brownie mix and enjoy the result without worrying about the fat and cholesterol content.
The swap ratio is 1:1 once more.

Is Butter Better for you than Oil?

Although We can use butter in place of oil, you should only do so if you are completely out of the oil you require. While butter can help to make brownies softer, it is also a very unhealthy option.
Although butter has the same caloric content as regular oil, it is much higher in saturated fats, which have been linked to higher blood pressure and cholesterol, which can lead to disastrous consequences such as heart disease or heart attacks.
Oils may contain the same amount of fats as butter, but these fats are better for gut health and are less likely to clog arteries. To avoid these risks, you should not make your brownies with butter instead of oiling them all the time.
If you decide to make brownies with butter instead of oil, eat them in moderation to avoid increasing your risk of a heart attack.

What Oil Substitutes will Affect My Brownies’ Overall Flavor?

As previously stated, olive oil can overpower your brownies, so go for the light or extra light versions. We will alter the flavor if you use too much avocado, sunflower, or coconut oil, so be careful with your measurements.

Which of the Listed Substitutes will Alter the Color of My Brownies?

Most oil substitutes won’t detract from the appearance of your brownies, but fruit puree, such as applesauce, will add a hint of color to the final product, depending on the type of fruit you use. An avocado, for example, is green, while a banana is yellow.

What can I Do to Keep My Brownies from Turning Greasy?

Brownies can become greasy as the fat separates from the batter, causing the grease to separate and surround the brownies.
If you want to help prevent your brownies from becoming greasy, try adding a little more milk to act as a binding agent and bring the elements back together.

Is it Better to Make Brownies with Oil or Butter?

When it comes to the final product, both taste and texture are very similar. However, due to the high cholesterol content in butter, using it in brownies is far more unhealthy and can increase your risk of heart disease.
As a result, it is generally recommended to use oil when making brownies for health reasons.

Conclusion

Have you decided which vegetable oil substitute is the best for brownies? We’re sure you have! Whatever it is, we are confident that the result will be spectacular and that it will not remain on the table for long. Now, brownie master, it’s time to use a tried-and-true trick with these substitutes.
We call it “the two-minute rule” because you’ll leave these little brownish guys in the oven for two minutes longer than the recipe calls. This ensures that your brownies have the same flavor and texture as the original recipe.
We hope you find this post and the replacements provided to be useful. Have fun, and make brownies!