Home » Cooking Tips » Can you Substitute Confectioners Sugar for Granulated Sugar in Baking Recipes?

Can you Substitute Confectioners Sugar for Granulated Sugar in Baking Recipes?

If you’re new to baking – or even a seasoned baker – you’ve come across an ingredient that has left you perplexed and scrambling for a substitute. Four sugars are used: granulated sugar, powdered sugar, confectioners’ sugar, and icing sugar. These ingredients are common in the baking world, and we frequently keep individual packets on hand.

There is no distinction between powdered sugar and icing sugar or powdered sugar and confectioners’ sugar; they are all essentially the same sugar, labeled differently. The distinction is between powdered sugar and granulated sugar.

What Exactly is Confectioners’ Sugar?

Confectioners’ sugar products, such as those sold by Dominos, are made with powdered sugar. Confectioners’ sugar is one of the many names for powdered sugar, and it’s also known as icing sugar. Powdered sugar is granulated sugar ground to a fine powder. So, if a recipe calls for confectioners’ sugar, know that it’s powdered sugar, which you should use.
Suppose you’ve ever wondered whether you could substitute powdered sugar for granulated sugar. But only in certain circumstances, such as when the powdered sugar is made at home.
The number of times powdered sugar has been ground distinguishes different varieties. A “10x” label indicates that the sugar has been ground ten times, yielding a very fine powder that dissolves easily. On the other hand, granulated sugar is more difficult to dissolve and has a grainier texture.

Can you Substitute Confectioners Sugar for Granulated Sugar in Baking Recipes?

You certainly can. So, if a recipe calls for confectioners’ sugar, know that it’s powdered sugar, which you should use if you’ve ever wondered if you could substitute powdered sugar for granulated sugar. “This means that a cup of powdered sugar contains more sugar than a cup of regular sugar.” Aside from inconsistencies in measurements, regular sugar does not dissolve and mix as well in recipes like frosting and icing, and the result will be a grainy, unappealing texture.
We can also use powdered sugar to replace up to 2 cups of granulated sugar, substituting 1 3/4 cup unsifted powdered sugar for each cup of sugar. This swap works best in moist quick bread and muffins. If possible, avoid using powdered sugar in recipes that call for creaming together butter and sugar.

Here are Top Substitutions for Granulated Sugar

These items will fit perfectly in your dish, and you will not be able to tell the difference. Continue reading to discover the differences and similarities between granulated sugar and other types of sugar.

Caster sugar

DHAMPURGREEN Castor Caster Sugar for Baking Cakes Cookies Pastries 5 Kg (5X1 Kg), Confectioners Sugar, Natural Sulphurless Pure White Sugar, Wholesale Granulated Powder : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Caster sugar is an excellent substitute for granulated sugar in recipes. It has a fine consistency, making it suitable for a wide range of desserts and baked goods.
1 cup caster sugar equals 1 cup granulated sugar
However, because the caster sugar crystals are not that large, you may need to add a little more but adjust accordingly to your recipes.
You won’t notice a difference in the taste of your baked goods.

Brown sugar

Sri Sri Tattva Organic Brown Sugar - 1kg (Pack of 1) - Natural & Refined Cane Sugar - Prime Quality - Rich in Minerals : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Brown sugar is an excellent substitute for granulated sugar. When making the swap, you can use a 1:1 ratio to achieve nearly identical results.
Remember that brown sugar contains molasses, which means it will change your recipe’s texture, taste, and color, but in such a subtle way that it may not be noticeable.
It is suitable for many desserts and baking goods to produce something tasty.

Powdered sugar

Amazon.com : Powdered Sugar By Unpretentious Baker (4 lb) For Baking, Candy Making, Desserts : Grocery & Gourmet Food

Powdered sugar, also known as icing sugar, is an excellent substitute for granulated sugar, and this will give your baked goods a denser texture while keeping the sweetness intact.
Remember that powdered sugar contains a trace of cornstarch in its texture. We can use powdered sugar to thicken recipes and sweeten desserts and sprinkle it on top of your desserts to make them even more delicious.

Honey

Amazon.in: honey

Honey is a widely available product that works well as a substitute for granulated sugar. It is a natural sweetener that We can use in many recipes that call for granulated sugar.
Because it has a different texture, you’ll need to cut back on the other liquids in your recipe. Honey will make your baked goods taste better, bake faster, and soften even more.

Molasses

Wholesome Organic Molasses Unsulphured, 32 Oz : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Molasses is another sugarcane or sugar beet juice that We can use to replace granulated sugar. The dark-colored liquid, which has a mild sweetness and distinct bitterness, can be used in place of granulated sugar in various recipes.
We can replace a cup of granulated sugar with 1 to 13 cups of molasses and a teaspoon of baking soda. Because they are liquids, they must be reduced by about 13%. Remember that molasses can alter the color and flavor of your recipe.

Agave syrup

Urban Platter Mexican Agave Syrup, 500g / 18oz [Natural Sweetener] : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

The sweet agave nectar will work well with granulated sugar in your recipes. It has a sweet flavor similar to maple syrup and honey, and the natural sweetness of this syrup will enhance the flavor and aroma of your dish.
Agave is also useful in baking, drinks, and other desserts and recipes. To get the correct amounts and a nice texture, reduce the liquid in your recipe by 14 cups.

Raw sugar

Just Organik Sugar, Raw and Unrefined 1kg, 100% Organic : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

We can use raw sugar in place of granulated sugar in recipes. The primary distinction is that raw sugar has larger crystals and contains more molasses. The bigger the crystals, the fluffier your baked goods will be.
If you want to reduce the crystals, you can always blend the raw sugar. Use it in most recipes, including baked goods, desserts, and cakes.

Coconut sugar

Cocoways Organic Coconut Sugar, ( 1.3 lb / 600 gm ) Glass Jar – Pack of 1 : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Coconut sugar is another type of sugar that We can use in place of granulated sugar; and it is similar, and you can add it in a 1:1 ratio to your baking goods.
It is made from coconut palm sap and has a pleasant natural sweetness. The flavor is sweet with hints of caramel and will work well in various desserts.
In many recipes, you can substitute one for the other.

Corn syrup

Corn Syrup : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Because of its sweetness, We can use corn syrup in place of granulated sugar in most recipes.
It is a purified and concentrated mixture of cornstarch hydrolysis. The flavor is similar to sugar and is slightly sweeter, so adjust the amount when making the swap.
For every cup of sugar, use 1 14 cups corn syrup and less than 14 cups liquid.

Maple syrup

Amazon.com : Kirkland Signature Organic Gluten Free 100% Pure, Grade A Amber Rich Maple Syrup - 1 L (33.8 oz) : Grocery & Gourmet Food

Maple syrup is a common ingredient in many dishes and a good sweetener that We can substitute for granulated sugar. Maple syrup has a unique flavor and sweetness that makes it suitable for various recipes.
To achieve the desired texture in baking goods, desserts, and many other recipes, combine 34 cups of maple syrup and 14 teaspoons of baking soda.
You should be aware that using syrup will not result in your desserts being cremated with butter. Cakes made with maple syrup will also be denser.

Cane sugar

Urban Platter Organic Raw Cane Sugar 400G : Amazon.in: Grocery & Gourmet Foods

Cane sugar, similar to granulated sugar, is another suitable substitute, and this is a similar type of sugar made from sugarcane. The crystals can be larger than granulated sugar and have a golden color.
You can substitute granulated sugar in almost any recipe that calls for it but adjust the amount before starting.

Bananas

Amazon.com: FRESH BANANAS FRESH FRUIT VEGETABLES PRODUCE PER LB : Grocery & Gourmet Food

You might not think of bananas as a sugar substitute, but they can be a good substitute for granulated sugar in many recipes due to their natural sweetness.
We can use them in a variety of baked goods and desserts. Sugar has less moisture than bananas. As a result, you must use half of the required amount of sugar and adjust accordingly.

Powdered Sugar Made From Homemade Granulated Sugar

If your recipe calls for powdered sugar and you don’t have any, you can convert granulated sugar to powdered sugar. All you need is a blender or food processor.
You can also add more cornstarch to keep the sugar from becoming soggy. Blend the granulated sugar for 4 to 5 minutes, then stop, stir, and repeat.
Check the texture until it becomes powdery and ready to use. After that, use what you need and save the rest because you can always use it later.

Can we Use Powdered Sugar in Place of Sugar?

It’s important to note that your powdered sugar output will be greater than your granulated sugar input. While this is fine when making a large batch, making individual recipe substitutions can become a problem. You’ll need about half as much granulated sugar as powdered sugar. For example, if a recipe calls for one tablespoon of granulated sugar, you can replace it with two tablespoons of powdered sugar, and the overall sweetness of your recipe will not change.

Keeping this in mind, you can successfully replace granulated sugar in tea and coffee with homemade powdered sugar. A good rule of thumb is to start with less powdered sugar and add more after tasting to ensure it isn’t too sweet. Store-bought powdered sugar (also known as confectioners’ sugar) will leave an odd aftertaste due to the presence of corn starch and is not recommended for use.

While some recipes combine powdered sugar and corn starch to help thicken sauces, others, such as a cooked sauce, maybe too thick and not the desired consistency if store-bought powdered sugar is used. Powdered sugar is also not a good substitute for recipes that require air to be incorporated into the batter, such as when creaming butter and sugar together. Granulated sugar absorbs water and has a larger surface area for tenderizing the mixture, so larger sugar granules are required in the dough-making process.

Is Sugar Used for Anything Besides Sweetening Baked Goods?

Sugar is used for more than just adding sweetness to baked goods, sugar adds flavor, texture, color, and structure to baked goods. Sugar delays egg coagulation and allow a cake to “set” properly in fat-free cakes. It also keeps moisture in baked goods, making them softer and pliable. When brown sugar is heated above its melting point, it caramelizes, resulting in a beautiful golden-brown appearance on the food’s surface. The more brown sugar you use, the darker your cookies, bread, or rib rub will be.

Can we Use Powdered Sugar in Place of Granulated Sugar?

Powdered sugar, also known as confectioner’s sugar, icing sugar, or 10x sugar, is an excellent recipe substitute for granulated sugar. Powdered sugar is created by simply grinding granulated sugar into a fine powder. When substituting powdered sugar for granulated sugar, use 1 cup, or 3/4 cup unsighted powder or 2 cups sifted powder for each cup of granulated sugar. This alternative will make your baked goods smoother and denser. Using powdered sugar keeps the sweetness level the same as granulated sugar.
Because powdered sugar contains a trace of cornstarch, it may cause sauces and puddings to thicken more quickly. Even though powdered sugar is fine granulated sugar, We cannot use it in recipes that require air to be incorporated into the batter. For example, consider creaming butter and sugar, and cookies made with this substitute will not crisp up. For baking bread and muffins, use powdered sugar.

What is the Difference Between Granulated Sugar and Caster Sugar?

Because granulated sugar and caster sugar are commonly used in our kitchens, you should understand their differences and similarities. They can both be used as substitutes for each other, but you should be aware of a few facts before doing so.
The size of the grain distinguishes these two types of sugar. On the other hand, granulated sugar has larger grains, and Caster grains are smaller and more easily dissolved.
You can use both to make delicious desserts, cakes, and baked goods by adding crunchiness and flavor.

What is the Distinction Between Powdered Sugar and Granulated Sugar?

The primary distinction between powdered sugar and granulated sugar is the particle size. Granulated sugar particles are larger and are made up of large sugar granules. On the other hand, powdered sugar is lighter and less dense because it has been ground to a fine powder. Two tablespoons of granulated sugar yield about 1/4 cup of powdered sugar.

How do you Make a White Sugar Substitute for Baking?

When substituting brown sugar for white sugar in baking, use a 1:1 ratio. The sweetness will remain unchanged, and you will not notice much difference. Always make adjustments based on the ingredients and the recipe.

Can Brown Sugar be Used in Place of Granulated Sugar?

Brown sugar is an excellent substitute for granulated sugar, and We can use it in almost any recipe that calls for granulated sugar. Use a 1:1 ratio and incorporate it into various desserts, cookies, cakes, and other recipes.

How Much-Powdered Sugar Equals How Much-Granulated Sugar?

We can make powdered sugar with approximately half the granulated sugar specified. If the recipe calls for one tablespoon of granulated sugar, you must substitute two tablespoons of powdered sugar to achieve the same sweetness.

Conclusion

Even the most well-stocked kitchens occasionally run out of pantry staples. We’ve got you covered if you’re trying to cut back on your grocery shopping or need to make a last-minute ingredient swap. This series will walk you through the best-powdered sugar substitutions and replacements for granulated sugar.