Home » Cooking Tips » Egg Substitutes For Pumpkin Pie

Egg Substitutes For Pumpkin Pie

A delicious pumpkin pie prepared without eggs! Yes, an eggless pumpkin pie is possible, and it’s quite simple to create. I’m sure you have the secret ingredient in your pantry. If you don’t consume eggs, have an allergy, or just ran out, this egg-free pumpkin pie is the solution.

For pumpkin pie recipes, there are a variety of egg replacements available. These egg-free substitutes are usually simple to calculate and can be found on the container. Potato starch, tapioca flour, and baking soda are commonly used as egg substitutes. You can try brands like Bob’s Red Mill and NutraSweet. The advantages and disadvantages of each are listed below.

What Can I Substitute in Place of Eggs in Pumpkin Pie?

  • Avocado

Amazon.com: Fresh Avocados - Fresh Avocados / Fresh Fruits: Grocery &  Gourmet Food

You’ve come to the correct place if you’re looking for an egg substitute for pumpkin pie. The avocado works well as an egg substitute in pumpkin pie. Avocado has a creamier texture than other fruits, and it helps to keep the pumpkin pie filling stable and thick. The pumpkin and avocado combine to give the pie its traditional fall flavors. It’s an excellent choice for vegan and egg-free pie fans alike.

Avocado is a healthy alternative for people looking for something different. It’s high in omega-3 fatty acids, fiber, and vitamins. Avocados can be used to make baked items that are low in cholesterol and fat in addition to adding moisture. To make a smooth paste, mash an avocado and combine it with a little water.  It’s easy to blend avocado into a smooth texture and will give your baked goods a unique flavor.

  • Flaxseed

Amazon.com : Premium Gold Whole Flax Seed | High Fiber Food | Omega 3 |  96oz : Flaxseeds Spices And Herbs : Grocery & Gourmet Food

Eggs are a necessary ingredient in baking, and substituting them with flaxseed is one of the easiest ways to make your favorite dish vegan or gluten-free. This oily seed is high in fiber and minerals, as well as omega-3 fatty acids, which are important for cardiovascular health. If you want to avoid using eggs entirely, flaxseed is a fantastic substitute.

In a spice grinder or coffee grinder, ground roughly a tablespoon of flaxseed to form flaxseed flour. Fill the grinder halfway with flaxseed and grind until it’s a fine, gelatinous meal. To make a paste, add water to the flaxseed and stir well to blend. For one egg in pumpkin pie, around one spoonful of flaxseed meal is required.

Flaxseed and chia seeds can both be used as egg substitutes. Up to 45 eggs can be replaced by one pound of either type of seed! Both seeds can perform the same functions as eggs: they can act as a binder in baked goods, add moisture, and aid in rising. One tablespoon of ground flax or chia seeds is mixed with three tablespoons of water and allowed to sit for 10 minutes until thickened.

  • Honey

Amazon.com : Great Value Clover Honey, 12 oz : Grocery & Gourmet Food

If you don’t want to use eggs, coconut oil can be used instead. Coconut oil has a medium smoke point and is nonstick. It contains medium-chain triglycerides, which help you lose weight by burning calories. Another fantastic egg substitute for pumpkin pie is honey. Honey’s sweetness complements the pastry in the pie. Honey can also be used to make a sugar substitute.

When exchanging an egg for an egg, it’s important to pick the best product available. Dark-hued honey will add a more subtle flavor to pumpkin pie. Buckwheat honey is overpowering. Coconut milk is another nice option. In addition, instead of conventional butter, use almond or coconut milk. Honey can also be used as a substitute for pumpkin pie spice. You can keep the leftover pie in the freezer for up to five days.

  • Mashed Bananas

Amazon.com: Fresh Organic Bananas Bundle (3 lbs.) : Grocery & Gourmet Food

If fresh eggs are unavailable, mashed bananas can be used as an egg substitute in pumpkin pie. Bananas have a texture and flavor that is comparable to eggs, and they will blend well with the pumpkin flavor. Silken tofu is another fantastic egg substitute for pumpkin pie. If you don’t have silken tofu, a piece of tofu can be blended in a blender.

There are many different kinds of mashed bananas that can be used to make pumpkin pie. Hemp seed milk or coconut milk can also be used. Chia seeds are also available online and in health food stores. They can be used in place of eggs 1:1. You should be warned that chia seeds can result in an unappealing black speckled pumpkin pie. You can also use a store-bought or home-baked pie dough to make your own pie crust and filling.

If you can’t obtain real eggs, high-pectin fruits and vegetables can be used to produce your own. Mashed bananas, canned pumpkin, sweet potato puree, and apple sauce can be used in place of eggs. Just keep an eye on the sugar content of the recipe, as too much banana can result in an overly sweet pie. Baking powder is a fantastic technique to make the recipe light without sacrificing flavor.

  • Aquafaba

Amazon.com : Vör Aquafaba Powder (7oz) | Vegan & Plant Based Egg Substitute  | Replaces 75 Eggs : Grocery & Gourmet Food

Aquafaba is the newest big thing in the egg-free baking industry, and you’ve probably heard of it. Stop before tossing the brine down the drain the next time you open a can of chickpeas because that’s aquafaba, which can be used to substitute egg whites. Because it possesses qualities similar to egg whites, aquafaba can be used as an emulsifier, leavening agent, and foaming agent. That means new vegan macarons, marshmallows, and meringues recipes. Use three tablespoons of chickpea brine to substitute one egg (another bean brines work also).

  • Silken Tofu, Yogurt, and Mayo

Amazon.com: Silken Tofu (Extra Firm) - 12.3oz (Pack of 12) : Grocery &  Gourmet Food

Silken tofu can be mixed until light and frothy, then used in baking to replace eggs. 1/4 cup blended silken tofu can be used to replace one egg. If you don’t have silken tofu, non-dairy yogurt and 1/2 teaspoon of oil would suffice. Don’t have any yogurt? What’s this? Vegan mayonnaise can also be used! Yes, for each egg you need to replace, use three to four tablespoons of vegan mayo. For a light and tasty dessert, use silken tofu in this Simple and Healthy Pecan Pumpkin Pie.

Can I Make Pumpkin Pie Without Egg?

It turns out that a pumpkin pie may be made without eggs. In fact, I believe an eggless pumpkin pie is easier than a classic pumpkin pie recipe, such as this pumpkin pie without evaporated milk, which you may have tried in the past. Having no eggs in the middle of a recipe is what I call a baking issue. Something I’m all too familiar with.

In fact, making a pumpkin pie without eggs is simpler. I believe you may have created a traditional recipe like this pumpkin pie without evaporated milk in the past. Having no eggs in the middle of a recipe is what I call a baking issue.

I recommend using a glass pie pan to bake your pie. This will allow you to determine if the bottom of your crust is thoroughly baked (nothing is worse than a soggy crust!). You should blind bake this style of pie first, which involves partially baking the dough without any filling. To blind bake your pie crust, you’ll need something to hold it down while it bakes.

What Happens if you Forgot to Put Eggs in Pumpkin Pie?

The lack of egg has no effect on the flavour of the pie; it is still excellent and spiced to perfection. Instead, it results in a watery texture similar to pumpkin pie soup.

The egg, I discovered, is what holds the filling together and maintains it in place. For the most part, this mixture retained the consistency of canned pumpkin and filled eight pie tins. My knife inserted in the center of the pies came out drenched with filling when the oven timer went off. I removed two of the small pies and cooked the remaining five minutes. Cutting the first two in half and removing them from the tins was practically difficult. It was like cutting into a melted ice cream bowl. The pies that had been baked for an extra five minutes were easier to separate, but the filling still flowed out. A thick coat of bright-orange skin covered both of them.

I took a mouthful and noticed that it had an odd consistency in the middle, which was cakey but wet at the same time. It reminded me of a sloppy cheesecake or a store-bought cookie that had been left in milk for much too long.

Can I Use Vegetable Oil Instead of an Egg?

Combine the baking powder, oil, and water. If you need to replace several eggs in a recipe, this is a wonderful substitution because it won’t make the baked good oily or modify the flavour character (like some other substitutes). By combining water, baking powder, and vegetable oil, you may almost perfectly imitate eggs.

To replace one large egg, combine one and a half tablespoons of vegetable oil with one and a half tablespoons of water and one teaspoon of baking powder. This is particularly useful in recipes that call for eggs as a leavening agent, such as pancakes and buns. f you need to replace one large egg in a recipe, you can substitute one tablespoon of vegetable oil with one tablespoon of water and one teaspoon of baking powder. This is especially useful for recipes that need eggs as a leavening agent.

If you don’t have any eggs or egg substitutes, this is a quick and simple way to produce them. If you’re missing one egg for the entire recipe, olive oil can be used instead. Simply add a quarter cup of olive oil to your recipe and you’re done.

What Makes Pumpkin Pie Weep?

Have you ever observed condensation on the top of your baked pumpkin pie? Though you might believe that weeping indicates that your pie needs more time in the oven, it actually indicates that you’ve overbaked it. The overcooked eggs in the custard filling are specifically to blame. Because the moisture separates from the hardened protein, an overbaked custard turns watery. You can’t go back in time if you overbake a pie, but you can make sure the next one is perfect by looking for a few telltale signs of doneness.

The bounce of the pie should be monitored. It’s time to remove the filling when the center still has some give, or “jiggle.” (An overcooked pie will have no jiggle.) Keep an eye on the colour of the filling, as it will deepen and puff out as it gets closer to completion. If you’re not confident in those methods, try the old standby: Close to the crust, insert a knife into the filling. “Moist but clean” should be the result.

When it comes to overbaking, it turns out that weepiness isn’t your only concern. Another common pumpkin pie issue is a cracked top, and it seems that no matter how precise we are with the time, the cracks appear. What’s the answer? Use an instant-read thermometer to determine whether or not your pie is done. When making candies or grilling chicken, we rely extensively on thermometers, so why wouldn’t we do the same with pie?


When it comes to holiday treats, pumpkin pie is a must-have. However, most pumpkin pie recipes call for eggs, so individuals like my kid who require egg-free pies are out of luck. To me, a holiday isn’t complete until you’ve had a slice of pumpkin pie.

The flavour of this eggless pumpkin pie is rich, smooth, and spiced. It may resemble a typical pumpkin pie, but it has no eggs. I adore how it turned out and how simple it was to make. It’s ideal for people who are allergic to or intolerant to eggs. Instead of a no-bake filling, try a stove-top baked filling thickened with cornstarch. The silky texture of the cooked and chilled “custard” is halfway between pudding and, surprise, a soft custard. While the filling does not require baking, it does require overnight chilling, so prepare it the day before Thanksgiving.