Skip to Content

What Does Pina Colada Taste Like?

The original pina colada recipe calls for Don Q golden rum, and it has a distinct flavor and shines in the sunshine. Don Q white rum is best for a mellow, subtler drink. If you prefer a sweet drink with a mild alcoholic flavor, go for a white rum. The pineapple juice should be freshly squeezed, but most bars use boxed pineapple juice.

A pina colada is a refreshing tropical drink, but it doesn’t contain alcohol, so you can enjoy one anytime, anywhere. The main ingredients are coconut milk, lime juice, extra-fine sugar, and coconut water. You can also use many different kinds of rum, including white, light, and dark.

You can also add shaved ice and garnish with pineapple or maraschino cherries. A pina colada can be made with any combination of these three ingredients. Typically, you’ll want to use a coconut milk-based beverage, which is less sweet than the traditional cream of the coconut.

What Does Pina Colada Taste Like?

The essential ingredients for a pina colada are rum, lime juice, and pineapple. You can use any of these ingredients in a pina colada, and it’ll still taste great. It’s not hard to make a pina colada, but it’s essential to make sure you use the best ingredients. It should be refreshing, but it should be made with care to avoid the sourness that often accompanies it.

Another critical ingredient for a pina colada is a cream of coconut. This is the crucial ingredient that gives the drink its signature taste. It isn’t sweet, so don’t add additional sugar. But if you’re a fan of the coconut flavor, you can add a teaspoon or two of it. If you’re looking for a low-calorie version of this tropical drink, you’ll find it in most supermarkets.

While making a pina colada, remember to buy a high-quality coconut cream. The best brand of coconut cream is Coco Lopez, and it’s worth spending a little extra money. If you don’t want to spend money on a cream of coconut, you can simply mix it with crushed ice and lime. Once you’ve tried this drink, you’ll know exactly what it tastes like!

What’s In A Pina Colada?

While there are many versions of the basic pia colada, the three ingredients are always the same: pineapple, coconut, and rum. Each of these ingredients is included in different amounts and in different ways in different drink varieties. Freeze the pineapple before blending it with rum and coconut juice if you’re making a smoothie. If you want to make a genuine cocktail, go with pineapple juice instead.

Using a different type of rum is another way to spice things up. A white or light rum is recommended in many recipes, both for color and a lighter flavor. You can also add garnishes to your finished drink. Pineapple slices and maraschino cherries are common garnishes, but you can use whatever complimentary garnish you like.

Aren’t Pina Coladas Not Healthy?

On its list of harmful cocktails to avoid, it includes a 560-calorie pia colada, though to be fair, this isn’t a problem specific to Bahama Breeze’s rendition of the drink.

Go to Lucy Buffett’s Lulu’s in Gulf Shores, Alabama, if you want to pile on even more calories. The restaurant, owned by Lucy Buffett, Jimmy Buffett’s sister, serves an ice cream-based pia colada. The drink is so popular that a duplicate version can be found on All Recipes. The recipe calls for frozen pia colada mix, crushed pineapple in syrup, and a cup of vanilla ice cream, and it’s dubbed the “Next Best Thing to Lulu’s Pia Colada.” There are 640 calories in each serving, 10.6 grams of fat, and 34.9 milligrams of cholesterol.

Marie Callender’s, primarily known for frozen dinners, serves a pia colada at its restaurants and bakeries across California, Nevada, and Utah. Based on a daily calorie consumption of 2,000, the beverage has 92 grams of carbs and 83 grams of sugar, or around 31% of a person’s carb intake.

What Is The History Of Pina Colada?

The origins of the Pina Colada have been attributed to Puerto Rico. One story claimed that a pirate named Roberto Cofresi handed his crewmates a coconut, pineapple, and white rum beverage. He served this drink to his crewmates when he wished to cheer them up. Another legend about the creation of the Pina Colada is that it was invented by a bartender named “Monchito” at the Caribe Hilton Hotel. This hotel was the first to serve this drink in 1954. In 2004, the Governor of Puerto Rico presented the same hotel listed above with a proclamation commemorating the 50th anniversary of the Pina Colada. After so many stories and the cocktail’s tremendous popularity, Puerto Rico finally designated Pina Colada its official drink in 1978.

Variations Of Pina Colada

By using frozen pineapple instead of ice, you can reduce the ice used and produce a thicker, more decadent cocktail. Fresh (not frozen) pineapple can also be used, and all you have to do now is adjust the amount of ice to your liking. To make a non-frozen version, combine all components in a cocktail shaker, shake well, and drain the ice.

There are three types of coconut milk: coconut milk (coconut pulp mixed with water and strained), coconut cream (a richer variety of coconut milk made with less water), and coconut cream (cream of coconut) (a product containing coconut milk and sugar). Cocktails are traditionally made with coconut cream, but if you want less sugar, use coconut cream—it just won’t taste as sweet.

Typically, pia Coladas are made with white rum, but a combination of white and black rum works nicely in this lighter version. You can make an alcohol-free version of this drink by removing the rum.

Is Pina Colada Good for You?

The non-alcoholic version of the pina colada is known to be nutritious. Even if you don’t drink alcohol, you’ll have a great time with this cocktail. The primary ingredient in this cocktail is pineapple, which, as previously said, provides a range of health benefits. Pineapple is high in vitamin C, vitamin B6, thiamin, and dietary fiber, all of which are beneficial to our health.

Even though it contains no alcohol or additional sweetness, virgin pina colada is incredibly healthful and has a pleasant and sweet taste. Furthermore, coconut milk’s beneficial fatty acids might match our bodies’ requirements.

Despite being low in cholesterol, coconut is a good source of manganese and fiber. So, when you drink a pina colada, you’re drinking one of the freshest and most calming drinks available, as well as a terrific nutritional beverage.


When it comes to the ingredients that make a pina colada, the original recipe calls for pineapple juice and two cups of rum. If you’re unsure which rum to choose, try using a blend of both. A combination of both flavors will be great! Just make sure to use high-quality rum to avoid any unwanted alcoholic substances. It’s not hard to make a pina colada and stick to the original recipe.

While most pina Coladas are made with rum, some use pineapple juice and coconut juice. If you don’t want to use rum, you can use a blend of pineapple juice and coconut milk to create a virgin pina colada, and a white rum version is just as popular. While you can’t get creative with this recipe, you can try the ingredients to see which one you prefer.