Skip to Content

Button Mushroom Substitute

When you’re craving a delicious and healthy mushroom recipe but don’t have time to pick up a button mushroom, don’t worry! There are plenty of great options that will work just as well. Try Cremini mushrooms, also known as Baby Bellas. They come in clusters, have firm white gills, and thicker stems than button mushrooms. While Cremini mushrooms are native to Europe and North America, they were first discovered in Italy, called “Baby Bellas.”

Button Mushroom Substitute


Butter Mushroom Nutrition Fact

What is Button Mushroom?

The button mushroom is one of the most widely consumed mushrooms. It’s a tiny white mushroom with a thin stalk and a round cap. Button mushrooms are tender and firm, ideal for raw or cooked consumption.

These mushrooms are available all year and are grown in controlled environments. The “White Button,” a member of the Agaricus family, is the most popular button mushroom variety. Button mushrooms have a mild flavor and aroma similar to citrus, nutmeg, and cinnamon blend. Salads are their most common application, but they can also be found in soups, pasta dishes, and stir-fries.

Tips for Cooking Button Mushrooms

One of the reasons I enjoy white buttons is how simple they are to prepare. They have a strong flavor and are more forgiving in the kitchen than some wild mushrooms. Put them through the wringer!

When buying mushrooms at the store, look for young specimens with unopened caps and no signs of bruising or sliminess.

Clean – Too much time in water can turn the mushroom mushy, so just rinse them or wipe them down with a damp cloth. To make them crispier, make sure they’re scorched before cooking.

Storage – Agaricus bisporus will keep in your refrigerator for a week longer than many other mushrooms. Paper bags are preferable to plastic bags for storage, and if you take the time to wrap them on paper, they’ll last even longer!

Cook – These can be used in nearly any recipe. Prepare them in soups, stews, and stir-fries as desired. Use them to season meat, fish, poultry, or pizza. Marinate the vegetables, and grill them on skewers. Make mushroom duxelles with them by chopping them up. The only limit is your imagination!

However, the simplest way to prepare them is in a simple sauté. By chopping them up and sautéing them in a high-smoke-point oil, you can create delicious little flavor bombs that you can use in any recipe.

Substitute for Button Mushrooms

1. Cremini mushrooms are an excellent substitute for button mushrooms

Whether you are in a pinch or simply want to try a mushroom substitute, the Cremini mushroom is a great option. It’s an all-arounder mushroom that is great in soups, stews, and even burgers. While many things can be substituted for a Cremini mushroom, white button mushrooms are one of the best choices. Both mushrooms come from the same family, have the same savory flavor, and can be substituted in most recipes.

While cremini mushrooms are native to the grasslands of Europe and North America, not everyone can easily find them. This is where a button mushroom comes in handy. Buttons are often cheaper and a good substitute for a delicious mushroom. Buttons are also a great source of protein, phosphorus, and B vitamins. In addition to these, button mushrooms are good for salads, hummus, and sauces.

2. Shiitake Mushrooms

You’ve probably heard about shiitakes if you’re looking for a mushroom substitute for button mushrooms. These mushrooms are similar to button mushrooms but are more robust in flavor and texture. They’re also more readily available in dried form than fresh ones, so shiitakes make an excellent choice in many situations. In addition, these mushrooms are much easier to find than button mushrooms. Here are some tips for substituting shiitake mushrooms for button mushrooms:

The texture of shiitake mushrooms is chewier and more toothsome than common button mushrooms. They’re a suitable replacement for button mushrooms, as they add a pleasantly earthy flavor to your dishes. These mushrooms keep up to two weeks in the fridge. Before using them, however, you need to keep them in a brown paper bag to prevent them from drying out. You can also freeze shiitake mushrooms to enjoy their flavor for several weeks.

3. Oyster Mushrooms

A widespread substitution for oyster mushrooms is the white button mushroom. This type of mushroom is also called olive oysterling. It has a short stipe and olivaceous cap and a meaty flavor. It pairs well with sauteed dishes and purees, and they have a similar flavor and texture to the oyster mushroom. This substitute can be found both fresh and dried, and it is the preferred choice of many chefs.

Oyster mushrooms are seasonal and can be purchased online. Because they grow on wood, they don’t need to be cleaned thoroughly. However, it’s a good idea to blanch or saute the mushrooms before freezing them, as this ruins the flavor. To cut the oyster mushroom, simply snip off the firm stem from the center of the mushroom, and the rest of the mushroom will fall off naturally. You can then saute or stir fry the mushroom to get its full flavor.

4. Pinto Beans

Pinto beans are a button mushroom substitute used in many recipes. This legume is high in protein and fiber. You can either cook them through or serve them raw, and be sure to rinse them well before using them in recipes. They have a distinct flavor that will go well with curries and sauces. To make them taste like mushrooms, you can add some extra ingredients like onion and garlic to your dish.

Dried mushrooms are also a good option, as they’re less expensive but pack the same flavor. Use half the quantity in a recipe to get the same flavor as mushrooms. However, try experimenting with different substitutes, as they can change the flavor of a dish. Always taste the food as you go so you can adjust the recipe. If you don’t like the flavor of one mushroom, try another.

5. Sun-Dried Tomatoes

If you’re looking for a healthy alternative to button mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes are a great choice. These tomatoes are dried in the sun and treated with sulfur dioxide before being packaged. While they lose much water content, their intense flavor is well worth the time, effort, and money. Additionally, they are a great source of lycopene, a powerful antioxidant. Aside from providing a meaty, earthy flavor, sun-dried tomatoes can also protect your skin from UV rays.

Sun-dried tomatoes can perfectly replace traditional mushrooms in many Italian dishes. Their distinct flavor is similar to mushrooms, but they have a more robust tomato flavor. Like mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes are easy to cook and hold their texture. They’re also great for long-simmering meals, as their rich flavor makes them a natural choice. And they pair well with chicken, turkey, and even poultry.

6. Portobello Mushrooms

While both mushrooms are edible, portobello mushrooms are more flavorful. They contain higher levels of riboflavin and niacin, two B vitamins, and these vitamins help break down carbohydrates and amino acids and help produce hemoglobin, insulin, and antibodies. Portobello mushrooms have a more delicate taste than button mushrooms, and the flavor can sometimes be more intense when cooked.

Portobello mushrooms are similar to white button mushrooms but have a more distinct flavor. They are more flavorful than button mushrooms and are also more expensive. Buttons can be found in supermarkets in the same varieties as portobello mushrooms, but they are more expensive. When you shop for portobello mushrooms, be sure to buy them in the summer. Because of their larger size, they are also available in winter.

Some Famous Button Mushroom Recipies

Pancit Canton

Pancit is a quick and easy noodle dish by nature, and Melissa Miranda, chef-owner of Musang in Seattle, adapts it to whatever she has in the fridge. “This is a refrigerator pancit,” Miranda explains. “Carrots, celery, and whatever vegetables you want to use are always staples.” We’ve been conditioned to believe that it must be cabbage, carrots, etc. But if you have yellow squash on hand, why not use it? Why not throw in some peas if you have them?” Mushroom broth, made from dried mushroom powder, is almost instantaneous but far superior to any other vegetable-based broth.

Carbonara with Mushrooms

In this vegetarian carbonara recipe, mushrooms replace the traditional cured pork, but don’t worry—the dish still has plenty of flavors! The humble button mushroom is elevated to new heights thanks to a deep browning and the addition of garlic and shallots.

Stir-Fried Tofu and Mushrooms

If you have some extra time before making this stir-fry, press the whole block of tofu for 15 minutes between two layers of paper towels and a couple of large cans. As the tofu cooks, removing the excess water helps it become extra crispy.

Pot Pies with Mushrooms and Thyme

For this pot pie recipe, brushing the underside of the dough with egg wash creates an airtight seal, allowing steam to push the pastry lids into a dramatic dome during baking.

Mushroom Broth with Black Barley

Always soak your grains after purchasing them. When they’re hydrated, they’ll cook faster and more evenly, and the soaking liquid can be used in finished dishes.

Sandwich with Browned Mushrooms and Grilled Cheese

Nothing beats a delicious grilled cheese for speed and convenience. This grilled cheese gets a boost of flavor from the caramelized mushrooms.

Stuffed Mushrooms with Cheese and Walnuts on Toast

This is a recipe I adapted from a cookbook for a food styling class. The task was to recreate the appearance and feel of a recipe from a magazine or cookbook. This is a modified version of Gordon Ramsay’s book Healthy Appetite recipe.

What Else can I Use in Place of Button Mushrooms?

When you’re looking for a substitute for button mushrooms, keep in mind that cremini and portobello mushrooms are the same species. Cremini and portobello mushrooms are simply picked at a later stage of maturity than button mushrooms; cremini is similar in size to buttons but is brown in color, while portobellos are larger and have a richer texture. Each has a slightly different flavor than button mushrooms, but both will suffice as a substitute.

Shiitake mushrooms can also be used as a substitute for button mushrooms. Shiitakes have a deeper flavor and are chewier than button mushrooms, but they can certainly fill in for them.

Are White Mushrooms and Button Mushrooms the Same Thing?

They are exactly the same mushroom type. They’re all Agaricus bisporus, just at different stages of development: toddlers are white button mushrooms, teenagers are brown cremini mushrooms, and adults are brown portobellos that are much larger versions of their younger selves.

Is it Possible to Eat Button Mushrooms?

Raw or cooked, button mushrooms are delicious. Look for mushrooms with smooth caps and no soft spots at the market. While many cooks believe that rinsing mushrooms causes them to absorb too much water, a quick rinse is OK if the mushrooms are quickly patted dry and not left to soak in water.


Not all of them taste or look alike when it comes to mushrooms. You can’t go wrong with the list we have for you if you’re looking for a button mushroom substitute.

These mushrooms are all members of the Agaricus bisporus mushroom family, but they are at different stages of aging.

They have a distinct appearance and flavor, and you’ll notice the difference in your following recipe that calls for button mushrooms.