Skip to Content

How Much Butter to Substitute For Vegetable Oil

There are many reasons to replace butter in your cooking with oil. Some people simply don’t like the taste of butter, while others are allergic to dairy products. A significant reason to substitute butter for oil is dietary restriction. Vegans and vegetarians don’t eat butter because milking cows is considered more compassionate than producing beef, but they are still allowed to enjoy the flavour of butter in their food. People with lactose intolerance also avoid butter, but they can still use oil in recipes.

Instead of 13 cups oil, add 5 13 tablespoons butter. Butter is a fantastic substitute for vegetable oil in baking because it moistens the crumb and gives the finished product a rich flavour. For every cup of butter, you use, reduce the amount of liquid in your recipe. If you’re looking for an alternative to vegetable oil, keep reading.

Everything to Know About Vegetable Oil

Fruit seeds and other plant elements such as bran are used to obtain vegetable oil. Store-bought vegetable oil is typically a combination of several oils, such as soybean, corn, safflower, sunflower, and others, with no information about the product’s origins and manufacturing methods.

Vegetable oil’s neutral flavour does not overpower the dish, and its high smoke point (400-450°F) makes it the preferred frying oil.

The unsaturated fats in vegetable oils are partially hydrogenated to make margarine. The hydrogenated product is more rancidity resistant and more stable at room temperature.

How to Use Butter Instead of Oil in Baking?

Why not use oil instead of butter? Depending on the type of oil, it can give your baked goods a nuanced flavour and moisture boost. A decent rule of thumb is to substitute olive, canola, or vegetable oil for roughly 3/4 of the butter in a dish (for example, if the recipe asks for 1 cup of butter, use 34 cups of oil). When it comes to coconut oil, you can utilize a 1:1 ratio.

However, there are a few factors to consider when substituting oil for butter in baking:

Butter is necessary for many recipes (particularly sure desserts) because it adds structure. When you cream butter and sugar for a cake, you create a swarm of tiny air pockets that combine with baking powder or soda to give the cake a light, fluffy texture. If you only used oil, the cake would be much denser than you desired.

If you’re not sure, use a 50/50 butter and oil mixture instead of entirely replacing the butter. The oil will add moisture without sacrificing the structural integrity that butter gives.

When Cooking, How to Replace Oil with Butter?

When cooking, butter can easily be substituted for oil (and vice versa). However, because butter contains both water and milk solids, it’s not always as straightforward as you might expect. When cooking with butter instead of oil, keep these tips in mind:

Pan-frying or sautéing? Before adding the remaining ingredients, let the butter bubble, melt, and settle on low heat. This permits the fat to reach the desired temperature while also removing some moisture.

Try not to stir-fry with ordinary butter instead of oil because it will not withstand the high heat. Instead, use clarified butter or ghee.

Use clarified butter or ghee for high-heat roasting.

How do you Use Vegetable Oil to Grease a Pan?

Yes, you can grease your baking pans with vegetable oil. Vegetable oil is found in the majority of non-stick oil sprays. Vegetable oil does not burn because of its high smoke point. Because it has a neutral flavour, it will not overshadow the flavour of any other component in the dish. You may use vegetable oil to grease your cookware in two ways.

Simply rub some oil all over the pan using a paper towel.

Pour a small amount of vegetable oil into the pan’s bottom and spread it around with a brush.

How do you adapt a butter-based recipe to one that uses canola oil?

A: We’re pleased to report that this substitution is actually quite simple. When replacing butter with canola oil in baked goods, use 34 cups of canola oil for every cup of butter.

If you make a straight conversion (cup for cup), one of the other liquid ingredients in the recipe will need to be reduced. You want to keep your dough or batter’s consistency.

Quick bread batters and doughs, as well as yeast bread doughs, should have the same consistency. Some cookie doughs could have a minor variance inconsistency.

You should find that if you start using canola oil in some of your pieces of bread and cookies, you won’t need to make any changes. When you make this substitution, I think you’ll be amazed at the results of some of your baked goods.

Our recipe bank’s chocolate chip cookie recipe has received rave reviews, and I recommend trying this recipe to gain a “feel” for baking with canola oil.

What Should you do if your Cake has too Much Butter?

Butter is that not-so-secret ingredient that makes any cake, cookie, or cupcake taste better. However, you should always use a particular butter in your meal. If you accidentally add too much butter to the cake, the texture and flavour will change. So, what happens if you over butter the cake, and how do you remedy it?

If the cake has too much butter, you can add drying components like egg whites, flour, or baking powder to the recipe. Too much butter will result in an oily cake with a runny consistency. Alternatively, you can minimize the moisture in your cake by baking it for a few minutes longer.

What Happens if There is too Much Butter in the Cake?

We all know that anything above what is needed is terrible. The same principle applies to cooking. When baking something, the proportions of the ingredients must be considered. Baking is an art form, and using too much of something can spoil your work.

However, if you use too much butter in the cake batter, your cake will become moist and dense. The more butter you add, the moister the cake becomes. The cake will ultimately reach the breakpoint and get denser if you keep doing this. As a result, the cake will not set and will crumble.

When you use too much butter in a cake, it turns into a greasy brownie texture.

Another disadvantage of adding extra butter to a cake is that it reduces the sweetness of the cake and will ruin the cake’s flavour. To produce a decent cake, you must maintain a precise ingredient ratio. If you do not want your cake to collapse like a house of cards, you should add a particular amount of butter.

Changing the recipe and trying something new can spoil what you’ve made and result in a disaster. Stick to the main recipe instead for these reasons.

Butter serves various purposes in the cake and provides moisture and flavour. It functions as a leavening agent in the cake (a substance that causes doughs or batters to expand), which is why the cake has air spaces.

When butter is heated, it produces steam and carbon dioxide. This feature aids in the fluffy and softening of the cake. However, too much butter in the cake batter can liquefy the batter and prevent it from setting up when cooked in the oven.

What is the Best Way to Dry a Cake?

When it comes to preparing goodies, things don’t always go as planned. A cake has various characteristics that indicate if it is flawless or not. It will firm up and form a beautiful structure with a fluffy, moist feel. However, if things do not go as planned, they may become excessively moist and taste bad. You must dry out the cake before it becomes a mess in this circumstance.

It’s difficult, but not impossible, to dry out a moist cake. To produce a beautiful cake, you must adequately combine the components. It turns moist when you add too much butter to your cake batter by accident. Another explanation for the moist texture is that the structure cannot be produced if you use less egg than required. In the cake, eggs serve as a binding agent.

To improve the cake’s moistness, mix the dry ingredients in the right proportions to balance the batter.

Ingredients like egg whites and wheat can absorb moisture and cause the cake to dry up. When adding these components, you must exercise caution because too much of them will ruin your cake. This procedure can be used before the batter is baked in the oven.

Bake your cake for an additional 10 to 15 minutes if you notice it has too much liquid after it has been baked.

What is the Butter Content of a Cake?

It’s impossible to say how much butter to put in a cake, and it is always dependent on the materials and their proportions. No one can tell you how much butter to use while baking a beautiful cake. Your query should be: what is the butter-to-other-ingredients ratio in the cake?

You must follow specific parameters and almost all of the recipes to make a beautiful cake. You will be able to make any cake from scratch if you follow this rule.

Baking a cake requires understanding the proportions of ingredients such as flour, sugar, eggs, and fat (butter). A skilled baker continuously calculates the proportions of the ingredients before baking a cake that will set, swell, and taste precisely.

A cake contains two key components, or characteristics, that ensure it is properly baked. The first step is to build the structure, which is done with flour and eggs.

Another factor is tenderness and wetness, which is the polar opposite of the structure of butter (fat) and sugar production. These two opposite features must be precisely balanced. As a result, the cake is neither too dry nor too soft.

The cake structure is held together by flour, sugar, and the two main protein elements. Your cake will become rough and dry if you use too many structure-building components in the batter. When you use too much sugar and butter in a cake, the structure will be destroyed, resulting in a soupy mess when heated.

It’s crucial to follow a proper recipe because it includes the balanced elements to keep the cake together. Your cake will be delicate and moist, with a beautiful taste if you follow the recipe strictly. You don’t have to follow the recipe to the letter; if you’re careful, you can stray 15-20% from it.

Now that you’ve learned and comprehended the information, it’s time to study the ratio and find the answer to the question. The butter should be about the same weight as the eggs or slightly less. You must exercise caution because this is all about weight, not quantity or volume.

A fully cooked egg weighs about 1.75 ounces. If your recipe calls for 4 ounces of butter, you should balance the cake with two eggs.

However, an egg has two distinct components that function differently in a cake. The white component of the cake dries it out, while the yellow yolk part gives it a silky texture. One entire egg and three yolks, weighing roughly 3.75 ounces, might be used to balance the weight.


Butter is an excellent substitute for vegetable oil. But before you start using it, be sure to melt it first. Oil and butter are very different, and butter will have a more savoury taste and texture. The main difference between these two substances is how they change with heat. Butter can be quickly melted and combined with other ingredients, while oil tends to remain a more dense liquid. Here are some tips for deciding which one to use.

Vegetable oil is a neutral flavouring fat with a high smoke point. This characteristic makes it ideal for high-heat cooking methods, but be aware that it will give off an unappealing flavour if heated above 450 degrees. This is the most critical consideration when substituting oil or butter. When baking, you can use the same amount of either. If you’re unsure of the exact amount of oil or butter you need to substitute, you can always experiment by trying both to see which one you prefer.