Skip to Content

Substitutes for Broiler Pan

Many people prefer the broiling method of cooking food to other methods, and for a good reason too. Broiling allows for healthier cooking procedures since it uses direct heat and excludes fat and oil. This is great because it reduces the risk of cholesterol-related diseases.

The broiling process also adds a lot of flavor to meals since it mainly cooks their fat. Furthermore, it introduces a caramelized flavor to meals that have been made using other cooking procedures.

Broiler pans are essential cookware that is difficult to overlook in the broiling process. They are excellent for indoor and outdoor cooking and make a wonderful addition to the vital utensils in any kitchen. However, they may not always be available at your fingertips for use, and so it is necessary to consider using alternative knives in their place. It is also essential to understand how to properly use these replacements for broiler pans to arrive at the desired cooking results.

What is a Broiler Pan?

A broiler pan is cookware, also known as a broiler roaster, oven roaster, or oven broiling pan. It is used to broil dishes such as steaks, roasts, or various types of meat, poultry, and vegetables in the oven. They are usually made of stainless steel or heavy-gauge steel with black porcelain enamel.

Broiler pans are composed of two essential constituents: a low-walled pan and an upper cooking surface that functions as the lid of the boilerplate. The broiling food is held in place by the cooking surface or cover. This cover has open slits and small holes, and the drippings from the food being cooked are caught in the pan below. The lid’s small apertures keep hot fat and drippings within the pan, preventing them from flaming and burning the bottom of the food as it broils.

A broiler pan may be sized to fit a variety of ovens and cooking activities, with a cooking surface ranging from 6 to 12 inches wide and 10 to 18 inches long.

Broiler Pan Uses in Recipes

Broiling is a method of cooking solid food items that use dry, direct heat. The meal is typically put directly on the heat source for broiling. Broiling imparts a lot of flavor to dishes since it predominantly cooks the fat. You can also use broiling to give food items that have been cooked in other ways a caramelized texture.

As their name implies, broiler pans are essential in the broiling process of making some mouthwatering recipes. Popular recipes in which broiler pans are used include:

Substitutes for Broiler Pan

A broiler pan in your kitchen helps you cook wholesome, healthy meals, promoting a healthy lifestyle. It’s a low-calorie cooking method since it cooks your food to perfection with little or no oil.

However, a time might come when you find yourself in need of a broiler pan but don’t happen to have any. There’s, however, no cause for alarm! There are several substitute options you can use in its place to achieve the results you would prefer in your recipes. Some of these replacement options are described below:

Cast-iron Griddle Pans

Cast-iron Griddle Pans


Cast-iron pans are typically manufactured from a single cast-iron piece. They’re adaptable, long-lasting, and help make delicious meals. This is primarily due to the material employed, cast iron, an excellent heat conductor that can withstand extremely high temperatures.

Some of these pans are enameled and more ‘nonstick’ while others are not and thus require continual cleaning. Because these pans can withstand extreme heat, they will not be damaged by being placed near the broiling food. Also, the long handle and grab handle components on griddle pans make transporting them much more accessible.

When shopping for cast-iron pans specifically for broiling purposes, consider buying those with griddle lines, which can replace a broiler lid or wire rack. Their lines should also be high enough to prevent the food item from sitting in its fluids.

Baking Sheets

Baking Sheets


A baking sheet, also known as a baking tray or sheet pan, is a rectangular metal pan made commonly from aluminum or stainless steel. Bread rolls, pastries, pizzas, and the likes are frequently baked with it. They aren’t anything close to broiling trays in terms of design, but in a pinch, they’ll suffice.

Baking sheets are built of the same materials as broiling and roasting pans, allowing them to resist extreme heat. Line a baking pan with aluminum foil (for easier cleanup) and place the food item on top. Place the tray as close to the broiling element and continue cooking in the usual broiling method.

It is critical to keep the amount of moisture in the food item to a minimum by avoiding marinades and sauces. Also, ensure to keep an eye on the meal in case the fluids start to catch fire.

Roasting Trays with Wire Racks

Roasting Trays with Wire Racks


Roasting trays are terrific and perhaps the best alternative to broiling pans. These trays are designed to help with air circulation around the food when roasting. When put near the broiling food, they behave similarly to actual broiling pans.

However, the main challenge you might encounter is that the juices from the broiling food can catch fire in the high heat. However, simply keeping an eye on your food can help avoid this.

It is important to remember that roasting trays should not be used on their own. They should be used together with a wire rack, effectively producing a makeshift broiling pan. The wire rack will aid in the drainage of juices into the “drip tray.” You can also purchase roasting trays with pre-installed wire racks.

Aluminum Foil Trays

Aluminum Foil Trays


Aluminum trays are inexpensive and come in several sizes and shapes, making it simple to find one that suits your preferences properly. When choosing an aluminum foil tray, search for those labeled “heavy-duty,” as not all types are. They are a last-resort option, but they enable quick and easy cleanup, saving you a lot of time and work. Aluminum foil trays can also resist the extreme heat that the broiling process necessitates.

The food to be broiled touches the tray directly, just like it does with baking sheets. Fortunately, no lubrication is required because it reacts with the food as aluminum foil does. You can, however, brush the food with oil to be on the safe side and for added flavor and color.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What pans are safe for broiling?

Unless your nonstick cookware or bakeware indicates that it is “broiler-safe” or “safe up to 550°F,” all-metal pans such as stainless steel or seasoned cast iron are your safest option.

Can you broil something in a glass pan?

Even if solid and enforced, putting a glass beneath a broiler is not recommended. Instead, use a heat-resistant metal pan or rimmed sheet pan.

Is broiling the same as baking?

Broiling differs from baking in that the food is surrounded by hot air and cooks slower. To keep a protein-like chicken moist, some cooks propose a two-step method of baking followed by broiling.


Incorporating the broiling process into your recipes is a beautiful way to add a lot of flavors and relish to your meals. It is also a very healthy cooking option because of the way it excludes fat. Do we recommend it? Yes, absolutely!

A broiler pan is an effective cookware option to go with when broiling your food items. But, when it turns out you don’t have access to one, you can always improvise. Try out one or more of our suggested substitutes for the broiler pan, and you’ll be delighted to find out how excellently they work!